We watch a lot of them.
I pick my battles and have decided the cartoon issue is not one of them.
I had every intention to be one of those no TV moms. I totally understand why a parent would make that decision.
Greg and I don’t watch a whole lot of TV ourselves. We don’t even have cable.
(But we do have Netflix, Halleluiah!)
We started out pretty solidly against television time. Rylie only watched Baby Einstein if I absolutely had to do a particularly tedious household task or if I needed to hop in the shower and it wasn’t nap time.
I might even venture to say we would still be pretty minimalist when it comes to TV, except that I got pregnant with our second child a little earlier than planned. During pregnancy I was always really, really tired and often sick.
What can I say? TV helped.
A lot.
Somewhere near the end of that pregnancy, I realized I had lost the no TV battle. By this time, Rylie was in the throes of a passionate (but sweet) love affair with Elmo.
And much to my surprise, so was I.
So now we watch a lot of cartoons and preschool entertainment.
Do I feel guilty about this?
Yes, I do.
Do I sometimes turn off the TV and send us all outside to play?
Not often enough, but as much as I can during agreeable weather.
I have found that Rylie’s love for books has not been compromised . And neither has her imagination. If anything, it seems to have been fueled by her cartoon counterparts. So that eases the guilt.
Somewhat.
I do have standards. We don’t watch much TV on weekends. And we only ever watch cartoons intended for small children. So no Spongebob, and certainly not Bratz. Anything remotely violent, even animated Spider Man, is not allowed.
At least not when Mommy is home.
As I mentioned, we don’t have cable but I do occasionally buy a DVD of Nick toons or something similar. And we have now discovered the joy of Netflix, which is all too convenient when streamed instantly through Wii. So our list of acceptable kid tv is on the rise.
And of course there is Disney, which I have never outgrown and never intend to.
But as far as daily television goes, we mostly stick to good ol’ PBS Kids.
I compiled a list of our favorites.
I so love lists.
Sesame Street I will go ahead and put it at the top. I adore it. I really do. I love the guest stars (Tina Fey and Adam Sandler). I love the characters (Cookie Monster is still my favorite but Mr. Noodle holds a special place in my heart). I love the humor, most of which sails right over kids’ heads. I love that they spoof current TV shows and movies (30 Rocks and Preschool Musical come to mind). And I love the educational value, of which I believe Rylie has benefited.
Oh yeah, and my kids really do love Elmo. Who doesn’t?
Caillou I used to hate Caillou. It is just so…Canadian. But I now have very maternal feelings for little Caillou. The writing actually seems pretty realistic and is incredibly easy for a toddler to grasp. Caillou’s life is like a lot of four year olds. His Mom stays home. He has a little sister. He is close to his grandparents. He goes to preschool. And he has a LOT of fears, many of which Rylie shares. His life so closely mirrors hers and she has learned a lot of positive lessons from him.
Still, I wonder about that gravelly voiced narrator. Is it or is it not Diane Reams of NPR? I ponder this question each and every afternoon.
Angelina Ballerina Rylie is enthralled with this precocious little dancing mouse who happens to harbor enormous diva-like tendencies. I worry that Rylie relates to Angelina a little too well.
The show is now computer animated but I prefer the older, hand drawn version, which is very quaint and English, which I love. Luckily, we still catch it via Netflix.
Thomas the Train This show terrorized Rylie for the longest time. Those things are pretty creepy looking. Big moon faces plastered to trains. She loves it now. We do not watch it often but I think I sing that song ten times a day.
Super Why and Word World Rylie likes them and I like that they are so super infused with early literacy skills. It’s a win win.
Martha Speaks Not Rylie’s favorite, but I like to watch it. The premise is very amusing (to me, at least). Martha is a dog who is mistakenly given a can of Alphabet Soup for breakfast one morning. As the song goes, “On the way to Martha’s stomach, the letters lost their way. They traveled to her brain. Now she’s got a lot to say!”
Barney is sometimes tolerated. I figure it could be worse.
I hate Dinosaur Train. I just have to say that. Luckily for me, so does Rylie. We don’t watch it.
But Greg does.
He loves it.
Confession: I sometimes catch myself watching these shows when the kids aren’t home. Why do I do this when I could be watching Oprah?